So there's this football league ...Where have we heard that one before? Many a failed enterprise began with those dangerous words. Those visionaries and entrepreneurs all meant well, but inevitably failed. So what is to make this AAFL thing different and relevant?
Beats me.
Not that I'm biased, but I love college football. And I love people being nice to me. This AAFL thing, its model is loosely based on college football and its local appeal. Argh. Its organizers: well, they send sometimes friendly, sometimes demanding emails asking us bloggers and writers to hype up their league. Requests = good. Demands = not so good. Can you see my grumpy face? Probably not, but it's there.
Can the league succeed? I have no clue, but only three professional football leagues have made it to the present: the NFL, the Canadian Football League, and Arena Football. What I notice is one monster league and two self-contained variants. What makes the Canadian Football League and Arena football successful may just be their willingness to be different from the NFL.
The CFL employs ginormous fields and slightly different rules. It's a more wide-open game. Arena Football plays indoors in way-too-cozy arenas because of its smaller field. The lesson from their survival where others failed is to be different.
It also helps to have some stars. The CFL is famous for playing big-name American players like Doug Flutie and Rocket Ismail and Ricky Williams. The AAFL needs to find itself some stars and no, former Florida Gator
Travis McGriff doesn't count. One lucky break is that the NFL recently dismantled its famous export: NFL Europa. There's a lot more freely available talent today than just a few months back, so maybe the AAFL gets lucky here with some seasoned players who aren't just retreads from the last failed domestic football league: the XFL.
Ultimately, I hunch the AAFL's road to success won't be paved with Trojans but rather a willingness to embrace a new way of playing football. If they don't ... well we know how that story goes.