On Sunday at the NFL Combine, we got our first glimpse of Matt Stafford and Mark Sanchez. And while it was difficult to divine much from, well, glimpses -- Stafford didn't take part in the passing drills and Sanchez didn't stand out in his handful of attempts -- it provides coaches, scouts and front-office types one more piece to the evaluation puzzle. Although conventional mock-draft wisdom has Stafford going before Sanchez -- and probably to the Lions -- those sentiments aren't shared among all scouts. Via the Chicago Tribune's Dan Pompei:
...[T]hree scouts the Tribune contacted this week said they rate Sanchez higher at this point. But because scouts know more about Stafford than Sanchez, many others have a greater comfort level with him. ...Hardly a ringing endorsement, but certainly something different than what we believe at our own peril online. Pompei makes the point that Sanchez has only started 16 collegiate games and that's obviously a concern for some teams (and Pete Carroll). But if he has a solid pro day, and does well in personal workouts, those issues could be mitigated.
One thing Sanchez has going for him is instincts. Several scouts agree he has more feel for the game than Stafford. That could help offset his inexperience.
Even if Stafford ends up going before Sanchez, there's still no guarantee the Lions will be on the drafting end of either. Chris Burke has made his case for taking an offensive lineman with the first-overall selection, and mlive.com's Tom Kowalski is on board, too.
"I don't think Andre Smith is an option at No. 1 and I don't think (Matthew) Stafford is an option at No. 1. The way things are going now, it's more likely the Lions would take Jason Smith or Aaron Curry ... They're playing it so close to vest, though, they're liable to do anything."(It's probably worth pointing out that Kowalski made these comments prior to Andre Smith's very public meltdown.) Taking an offensive lineman is the safe pick, and sometimes it's okay to go that route. Somehow I think Charles Rogers and Mike Williams would want it that way.



















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
2-23-2009 @ 6:05PM
horatiowrd said...
Take Mike Crabtree!!!
then Pat White.
Reply
2-23-2009 @ 7:47PM
Steel Wheel said...
I still think their best option is to trade the pick and build some quality throughout their roster. The only thing this high pick is gonna earn them is an exorbitant contract of a single player on a roster that needs an influx of EVERYTHING!
Reply
2-23-2009 @ 11:16PM
David Maziasz said...
I enjoy reading Tom kowalski's writings at the free press. He is thorough and offers good insight. I am glad you used him as a source.
I think Stafford is over rated because he plays such a prime position. I really hope the Lions pass on both these guys and draft either Jason Smith or Aaron Curry. Curry looked excellent at the combine today, which only confims everything on film of this guy: he is a beast.
If you don't mind, I'd really appreciate anyone leaving a suggestion or comment on my blog, http://www.NFLdraftblogger.com
Reply
2-24-2009 @ 8:47AM
John said...
draft both smith and curry,,,a set of bookends could be a start
2-24-2009 @ 8:45AM
John said...
There is no reason to send another quarterback to the slaughter,,,,,,,,,get some protection first, and i think you will be surprised at how well the existing quarterbacks can perform,,,,release culpepper, he is nothing but a bench warmer taking a future stars space
Reply
2-24-2009 @ 11:01AM
iluvroids69 said...
I really can't wait to see some of these assclowns when they need to find real jobs, my Eddie Shore wrote about it at www.dbbsports.com
Reply