It was a logical penalty according to the NFL rules, but that doesn't make it any less annoying that amusing NFL celebrations get fined. James apparently agrees too, because when he was informed of the NFL's fine on the Super Bowl MVP, he wasn't very impressed.
"Did he?" James asked. "That's disgusting."I'm not entirely sure about the whole "Buckeyes" thing, but I certainly do stand firmly in James' corner here: celebrations in the NFL are awesome as long as they're kept under wraps a little bit. Joe Horn and the cell phone hidden in the goal post a few years back? Probably a bit much, and a touch contrived. Chris Johnson and his impromptu bongo session? Just flat out awesome.
Asked if he thought such celebrations make the game more fun for the fans, James said "absolutely."
"Fun for the fans - fun for me," James said. "I was watching. Us Ohio State Buckeyes, we're alums, man. We've got to stick together."
And frankly, it would be nice if Roger Goodell would see the light, a la James, and understand that fans are, by definition, what make football so popular. And, for the most part, we love post-touchdown celebrations as long as they're clever and in somewhat good taste.
Life in the No Fun League'
Santonio Holmes celebrated his Super Bowl-winning touchdown catch by paying homage to LeBron James' pregame powder toss. The NFL fined Holmes $10,000 for the act, which was not penalized during the game. Click through to see more questionable NFL fines over the years.
James Borchuck, St. Petersburg Times / AP
Culprit: Darnell Dockett, Arizona Cardinals
What He Did: Dockett (No. 90) jumped on the back of teammate Antonio Smith and rode him like a rodeo bronco.
NFL Fined Him: $20,000
Kevin Terrell, Getty Images
Culprit: Wes Welker, New England Patriots
What He Did: Made a "Snow Angel" after scoring this Week 16 touchdown in wintry conditions versus Arizona.
NFL Fined Him: $10,000
Stephan Savoia, AP
Culprit: Shaun Ellis, New York Jets
What He Did: Chucked a large block of snow into the Seattle stands in retaliation for fans pelting New York's players with snowballs
NFL Fined Him: $10,000
Joe Robbins, Getty Images
Culprit: Benjamin Watson, New England Patriots
What He Did: Stuffed the ball up his jersey as an end zone tribute to his expectant wife and the couple's yet-to-be-born daughter
NFL Fined Him: $10,000
Otto Greule Jr, Getty Images
Culprit: Brandon Jones, Tennessee Titans
What He Did: Simulated an arrest during a touchdown celebration against the Jaguars
NFL Fined Him: $15,000
Doug Benc, Getty Images
Culprit: Ryan Clark, Pittsburgh Steelers
What He Did: Wore eye black with the No. 21 to honor his late Redskins teammate, Sean Taylor
NFL Fined Him: $5,000
Gene J. Puskar, AP
Culprit: Chris Johnson, Tennessee Titans
What He Did: Played the bongo drums on the sideline after a 66-yard TD run
NFL Fined Him: $10,000
Jamie Squire, Getty Images
Culprit: Ronnie Brown, Miami Dolphins
What He Did: Performed a choreographed "Cupid Shuffle" dance with teammates
NFL Fined Them: $10,000 each
Doug Benc, Getty Images
Culprit: Terrell Owens, Dallas Cowboys
What He Did: Mocked the Patriots' Spygate scandal by using the football to simulate a camera
NFL Fined Him: $7,500
Eliot J. Schechter, Getty Images



















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
2-20-2009 @ 11:41PM
Spleeve said...
Uhhhhhh - Holmes and Pittsburg got away with way more - that fine is nothing, and it's at least consistent - you can't show preferential treatment, like the officials did in the SuperBowl. Pittsburg should have been kicking off from their own 15 yard line - and the game would have been at least fair. Too bad the officials had to screw it up so bad. Another Superbowl handed to the Steelers. Seahawks fans know what I'm talking about.
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 11:26AM
luiginop said...
Your a hater. Haters only see the game one sided. Too bad you don't know the game of football very well. It was a excellent game.Your probably a cowboys fan. you should stop hating on the Steelers and start hating on your team that are a bunch of criminals. How bout those cowgirls!
2-24-2009 @ 1:29PM
BUSI690KAF said...
Spleeve, really? So, the Steelers should have been called for holding in the endzone and didn't have a tough call go against them all game?...really? What else did the Steelers get away with, really? Using the ball as a prop 15 seconds later?...really? You know all of this b/c of your great credentials as an NFL Official Assessor?...oh, really?
Get out of your conspiracy theory dungeon and enjoy a great game and a franchise that does it the right way, even if your team didn't get it done.
2-24-2009 @ 1:43PM
Spleeve said...
I was stating the facts about what happened. The refs overlooked an obvious 15 yard unsportsmanlike conduct and the Steelers should have been kicking off at their own 15 yard line. They also missed an illegal block in the back on Hightower during Harrison's interception return, which would have negated the touchdown. If you can't admit the truth, you are in serious denial. Don't be a blind Steeler idiot.
2-24-2009 @ 6:44PM
gcn said...
Sorry, Spleeve, you're doing a lot more than pointing out potentially missed/mistaken calls, you're suggesting preferential treatment (your words), basically a fixed game.
Why wasn't Holmes penalized for unsportsmanlike conduct after the TD? Because the conduct didn't come immediately after the catch. After the TD, Holmes got mobbed. After he got out from under the bottom of the pile, Holmes started walking back to the Pittsburgh sideline, still carrying the ball. During this time, play is being reviewed while the special teams are coming out for the PAT if the play isn't reversed. Then, just as he's getting back to the sideline, he starts with that Lebron-dance. That's why he didn't get flagged; none of the refs were paying attention to him at that point. The refs were either a part of the review or where on the field getting ready for the next play. The delayed in the celebration is why it wasn't observed or flagged. You don't think this is the much more likely reason a penalty wasn't called? You really think that it was actual favoritism by the refs? I'm not saying it wasn't a penalty or shouldn't have been called as a penalty if it was observed. I'm just saying that this is the much more likely reason why it was missed, as opposed to some crooked conspiracy.
Then you mention the supposed blocking-in-the-back penalty on Harrison's return, describing it as though it was obvious for all the world to see. I think you're completely wrong about that. I don't hear any credible "experts" (reporters, writers, analysts, etc.) pointing to this as a missed call. Hell, I didn't even hear Arizona players or coaches complaining about that non-call. First, the Cards' player was in the act of turning towards the play as he was blocked, so this isn't typically called as a penalty. Second, even if could have been called as a penalty, hell, it's possible for something this close to get missed on any offensive or special teams play. I can go tit-for-tat with you on penalties against Pittsburgh that weren't called. That sure wasn't a situation where anybody who doesn't acknowledge it is blind (as you claim). In fact, it is the opposite. The silence over this non-call from amyone credible is deafening.
Even though I'm a Steelers fan, I can acknowledge that there were some missed or erroneous call in SB43. But I don't see any evidence in support of your claim that there was some actual intent to favor Pittsburgh from the refs or the league. That is clearly what you are saying, not just that the refs made mistakes.
2-24-2009 @ 6:48PM
gcn said...
Oh, and even if a penalty had been called on Harrison's pick 6, there was still at least 2 seconds on the clock, it hadn't expired. So I don't think its as simply as saying that a penalty would have negated the Pittsburgh TD. I'm not guaranteeing that Pittsburgh would have put a TD on a final play from scrimmage in the first half, the odds would certainly have been against it. But how ironic that so many of you anti-Pittsburgh fans claim (in very similar terms) that the Cardinals would have scored a TD at the end of the game if they'd had one final play from 15 yards closer.
2-25-2009 @ 11:14AM
cartproduce said...
yea and james harrison being held on every down too apparently you wasnt watching that huh, gimme a break you must be a ravens or browns crybaby
2-21-2009 @ 12:32AM
sadbear2 said...
Spleeve, love the comment! It thrills us Steeler fans when we see how miserable you"Steeler haters" are. It must really suck for you doesn't it Spleevey "boy" that the Steelers have won more Super Bowls than anyone else. Also, "Spleevey" have you checked the opponents for the Steelers in 2009? Looks highly likely that we'll be in the running for Super Bowl number seven. You shouldn't spend too much time though worrying about that. Instead, why don't you invest some time earning a GED so that one day you can work your way up to a menial job that pays minimum wage? "Pittsburg" is spelled Pittsburgh, you moron.
Reply
2-23-2009 @ 8:53PM
bob said...
right on sad bear idiots like spleeeve only count the penalties on one side of the ball wonder if he counted all the holding penalties the cards had.Steeler Nation Rules spleeeve get on board or quit your whining cause they are going to be around forever
2-21-2009 @ 12:58AM
Bob said...
Wow, LeBron, exactly when did you attend Ohio State? Last I heard, you skipped college and ran to the cash register instead. If you want to call yourself a Buckeye FAN, then great, but you have to EARN the right to call yourself an alum...of ANY college or university. That's like calling yourself a veteran because you like to shop at Army surplus stores and wear their gear. No, I'm not a LeBron hater, I just feel that no matter who you are, certain titles shouldn't be taken lightly--a lot of time, money, effort, and sacrifice goes into becoming an alum, and he made the choice to bypass that.
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 1:33AM
gcn said...
You go, sadbear! Jealous haters like Spleeve actually make me more proud to be a Steeler fan. If that idiot actually thinks the league is fixed, then he should just stop watching the NFL. Nobody is forcing him to do it. He can go back to watching ESPN World Series of Poker, or professional bowling, or whatever else he wants. What a loser.
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 8:04AM
BlueStarDude said...
Will, you're half right. Fines (and penalties) for TD celebrations like this one are ridiculous. But the commissioner can't let ones like this go and then turn around and fine a celebration because it lacks the same kind of creativity, or because it seems a bit too much. There's no accounting for taste after all. No, it has to be all or nothing. And the smart play on the commish's part would be stop fining these plays that always make it into the highlight segments for a reason: most fans enjoy them, or at least enjoy talking about them.
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 8:15AM
p1zzaz said...
i lovvvveeee touchdown celebrations to see what the guys would think of to top past celebrations. some are so clever and funny
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 8:30AM
Dennis said...
================ I DONT MIND THE TOUCHDOWN DANCES....BUT THESE GUYS ACT AS THO THEY JUST SAVED THE WORLD FROM EXTINCTION. COME ON DUDES....YOU JUST SCORED A TOUCHDOWN...NOT SAVED THE PLANET FROM NUCLEAR HOLOCOST.....========
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 8:32AM
barbkay37 said...
You have got to be kidding me! I am so sick of hearing about the $ related to NFL players, NBA, ect.! So many people are hurting and struggling but yet somehow we can still come up with millions of dollars to pay these players every year! That is _____ ridiculous! GREED and SELFISHNESS! Here's an idea.
Why don't these ridiculously high paid players show an act of compassion and respect to children in this world who are going to suffer from what they will lose in school due to cuts in the education system; not to mention the demeaning pay that teachers get. If it weren't for the teachers in this world, these sports players would NOT be where they are today. I think these players ought to DO THE RIGHT THING vs. GREED and hand over some of their millions in each state to help! If not; these players are NOT an exception or any better than all of the other hard-working jobs that are getting a salary cap or eliminated all together!
Reply
2-22-2009 @ 12:33PM
tony said...
Why should athletes share thier money they earned it, teachers, police,and fire fighters chose thier professions knowing they would not be rich. I myself am military and don't want thier money or a handout
4-18-2009 @ 7:49AM
Nick8708 said...
They earn their money because millions of people will watch them do what they're good at. If you want to look at how many people experience each player performing their job compared to how many people experience each teacher performing their job, the numbers would be significantly on the players side.
Not to mention the fact that while they make a lot of money themselves, hundreds, perhaps thousands of other people per player make money because the players are such a draw. Consider the owners, the coaches, the staff, the announcers, the commentators, the people who work in the stadiums, the people who work in the concession stands in the stadiums, the janitorial staffs, the field crews, the sports bar owners and staffs, the sportswriters, radio and television sportscasters, everybody who works at the NFL network, a large portion of the people who work for ESPN who wouldn't have jobs if football wasn't so popular, and the list can go on and on and on. These people can all have jobs because football is extremely popular; popularity equals demand and if you know anything about economics high supply and low demand means talented players are extremely valuable. And considering that getting into the NFL is extraordinarily difficult, NFL players are in a good position, and rightfully so, to make a lot of money.
So in short, while a relatively small number of people may make a ridiculous amount of money for just "playing a game", there are many, many more people per player who can make a living because of what these players do. Take away the game and you're looking at tens, maybe hundreds of thousands of people across the globe potentially being impacted financially. Ever think of that?
There's also a lot more wrong with your outlook but I think I'll stop there. It's people like you who try to make people feel guilty for being successful and it's really sickening.
2-21-2009 @ 9:56AM
Drolz said...
The only reason the No Fun League is so overcontrolling with trivial stuff like end zone celebrations is because they're compensating for the one thing they know they can't control: the use of performance-enhancing drugs. There are a lot of things pro sports needs to clean up, but end zone celebrations ain't one of them.
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 11:07AM
paul said...
wtf it's not like James owns the celebration or something. it's just a freaking celebration. sounds to me like the nfl is just fine happy or are drunk by their own power. the nfl needs to get real for once. it makes me wonder what they will do next that's dumb, pointless, and lame? they need to focus on getting better refs who can call a football game right and fairly instead of wasting their time and the players time by fining them for stupid s@#t like this.
Reply
2-21-2009 @ 11:10AM
waterlillies10 said...
the stealers will always be known by this name across the country, rooney+refs=stealer wins, the fine wasn't enough
Reply