TAMPA, Fla. – This morning in the Super Bowl media center, I spotted Buffalo Bills Hall of Fame coach Marv Levy chatting with a couple of members of the media who are members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame Board of Selectors. A little bit of eavesdropping revealed that Levy was lobbying on behalf of some of his players, and the Bills' longtime owner.One of Levy's old players, Bruce Smith, is eligible for the Hall of Fame for the first time this year. Smith is one of the greatest defensive ends in history, and he is virtually assured of being selected on Saturday. So Levy doesn't have a lot of work to do there.
But Levy has some more difficult lobbying to do on behalf of a couple of other men. This year's Hall of Fame finalists include another one of Levy's Bills players, Andre Reed, as well as the man who has owned the Bills for the franchise's entire 49-year history, Ralph Wilson.
I think Reed will have a very hard time getting in. As I previously noted, Cris Carter will have a close call in Saturday's voting. Carter appeared in more Pro Bowls and had more catches for more yards and more touchdowns than Reed, so if Carter is going to have a tough time getting in, Reed's path to the Hall of Fame is much tougher. As pro football continues to evolve, wide receivers are putting up bigger numbers, and Reed's look less impressive by comparison. Levy is going to have a hard time pressing his case for Reed.
Wilson's candidacy is a tough one to gauge. There's no question that he's been an extremely influential figure in pro football history, from getting the American Football League off the ground in 1960 to hosting the first regular-season NFL game in Canada in 2008. But Wilson will be judged on Saturday against 15 former players on the ballot. How do you compare an owner's accomplishments to those of a defensive end or a wide receiver? My guess is Wilson won't get in.
I also heard Levy lobbying for one of his old players who isn't among the finalists up for consideration on Saturday, center Kent Hull. Levy was pointing out that in the fast-paced, no-huddle, shotgun offense that the Bills ran in the 1990s, Hull had just about the hardest job any offensive lineman could have: He had to sprint to the line of scrimmage after a play, make the line calls quickly, and then deliver an accurate shotgun snap.
Levy makes a good case for Hull. It's disappointing that he's so far been overlooked in Hall of Fame voting, and I think if people like Levy continue to argue for his enshrinement, he's the type of player whose career might look more impressive over time, and some day he could get in. But for now, Smith is probably the only Buffalo Bill who will be part of the Pro Football Hall of Fame Class of 2009.



















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
1-29-2009 @ 10:27AM
mike said...
Levy, Jim Kelly and Thurman Thomas are already in the Hall of Fame. Bruce Smith will get in. If Ralph Wilson, Andre Reed and Kent Hull all get in, the Bills of the 1990s would have five players, a coach and an owner in the Hall of Fame. Isn't that too many for a team that never won a Super Bowl?
Reply
1-30-2009 @ 5:47PM
Jim said...
How many Super Bowls did Dan Marino win? I don't think that there is a fan of football that would deny him entry. Keep in mind that the Hall of Fame is an acknowledgement of a person's individual acheivements AND their contribution to the game. I think a valid arguement could be made for any of these men.
1-29-2009 @ 2:07PM
clearbeach said...
Ralph Wilson negotiated the American Football League Television contract in the early 60's. He got the AFL 900,000 compared to the NFL 1,200,000 from CBS. He leant the Oakland Raiders $250,000 secretively to keep the franchise afloat or we would not have had the Raiders. A couple years ago the pundits called him a crazy old man for being against the labor contract....amazingly enough the vast majority of owners now agree with him that the contract was bad....At any time he could have left Buffalo for a better pay day but did not...He is what a Hall of Famer in football and life should be.
Reply
1-30-2009 @ 10:55AM
kujo said...
I don't agree about Andre Reed. Look at the numbers - Reed (951/13,198/87/13.8 per catch)..Carter (1101/13,899/130/12.6 per catch). Sure Cris Carter had more catches and TD's, but remember that he played in a dome with Minnesota for the bulk of his career. The Vikings were a pass happy team at the time. Reed played in Buffalo, where after November 1st each year, you didn't know if you could pass the ball on any given day. Reed lost 10 games to injury in 1995 which definitely would have put him over 1,000 catches. He averaged over a yard more per catch than Carter; has only 700 less yards despite 150 less catches than Carter; and Carter never went to a Super Bowl. He is ahead of Monk and Irvin (both HOF's) on the all-time list. Once again, as he was in his career, Reed is under appreciated. He's Hall of Famer.
Reply
4-19-2009 @ 10:28PM
Bob said...
Ralph Wilson has been a fixture in Buffalo since the inception of the Bills but his history of poor choices in personal management and a mediocre overall record leaves me underwhelmed. The fact that he has shown loyalty to Buffalo while alive but is doing nothing to ensure the longevity of this franchise in western New York is another reason why this owner doesn't get my respect for "Hall of Fame" status.
Reply