Each week in the NFL, there are players that impress and players that distress. One week a certain quarterback might toss four touchdowns and run around with his finger in the air while the next he's laying on his back, holding his facemask as the other team returns one of his three interceptions for the game-winning score. With that in mind, here's Studs and Duds.Here's Week 10 at a glance, where we point out the horses destined for the Kentucky Derby and jeer those headed to the glue factory.
Studs
Thomas Jones, RB NY Jets (26 carries, 149 yards, 3 TDs) -- Three weeks ago the Jets looked absolutely dreadful, losing their third of four games and having people question just about every decision they'd made (i.e., Brett Favre). Well thanks to Jones, who has scored in three straight, all victories, New York looks like they could sneak in the playoffs and play the role of team you wouldn't enjoy seeing on the opposing sidelines. In the largest victory in Jets history, Jones found holes in a pitiful Rams defense and decided to hang out in the end zone three times. Mr. Jones, how does it feel to be the AFC leading rusher?
Brandon Jacobs, RB NY Giants (22 carries, 126 yards, 2 TDs) -- What, you think Jones is the only New York running back who can have a game? Jumping in the air not withstanding, Jacobs has turned into the toughest running back in the league, pummeling defenses like they were a college team out of Washington. While Eli Manning has had a couple of decent, not great, games, Jacobs has picked up the slack and continues to have the Giants winning games over tough opponents.
Maurice Jones-Drew, RB Jacksonville (11 carries, 70 yards, 3 TDs) -- You could blame a lot of the Jaguars' problems on their rushing attack this season. Jones-Drew has found his name on the other side of this list because of his lack of a presence, but not this Sunday. The bowling ball bounced off defenders, celebrating in the paint three times and keeping a slight shot at making the postseason in Jacksonville's grasp if they can get hot. The career high for Jones-Drew helped the Jags to their highest scoring total of the season by more than two touchdowns. Novel concept -- score points, win games.
The Week of the Tight End -- Honestly, we could have a "Stud: Tight End" category this week with all these crazy numbers. Tony Gonzalez, Bo Scaife, Todd Heap, Kellen Winslow, Dallas Clark, Kevin Boss, Antonio Gates, Dustin Keller, Daniel Graham and John Owens all found the end zone, with Tony Sheffler pulling in four catches for 92 yards without a score on Thursday. If you were wondering why your receivers weren't posting any touchdowns, it's because the tight ends were stingy this week. Obviously this paragraph is looking past the fact that Jeremy Shockey has hands made up of Acme brick.
Duds
Sage Rosenfels, QB Houston (294 yards, 1 TD, 4 INTs) -- I've decided to coin the phrase "Pulling a Sage" for anybody who has ever replaced somebody great with somebody not so great. You know, we all have that buddy with the beautiful, funny, intelligent girlfriend who he eventually dumps for the girl who looks like a walking bacterial infection. Well, that would be pulling a Sage. I think if I was Matt Schaub, I'd ask the Houston beat writers to avoid using the term "Texans quarterback" with Rosenfels just so people don't think the two play the same position.
Trent Edwards, QB Buffalo (12-for-23, 120 yards, 2 INTs) -- In the Bills' five wins, Edwards tossed five touchdowns to only two interceptions. In their current three-game losing streak, he's reversed that number, throwing five interceptions and taking the Bills from playoff lock to hopeful destination of Matt Stafford.
Marc Bulger and Trent Green, QB St. Louis (combined: 11-for-23, 135 yards, 1 fumble, 2 INTs, 1 hit referee) -- Yeah, the Rams are terrible, and a lot of that blame can fall on the quarterback position. These two gems combined for such a bad game I felt the need to include both parties. How bad was the game for the Rams? Head coach Jim Haslett said after the contest, "It was embarrassing. That was bad football all the way around. I can't even describe it." I can -- u-g-l-y.
Eagles' Play-Calling -- Granted I've never been that big of a Donovan McNabb fan, but the guy was molded for plays like the last one in the Sunday night game. Third-and-3 with the game on the line, the Eagles decide to run the ball on a defense that gives up yards like a homeless guy gives up quarters. Fourth-and-1 was the same play call, a Brian Westbrook run that seemed to be sniffed out before McNabb yelled "hut." You know the decision-making is bad when your star is questioning it to reporters after the game. "I want the ball, but the coaches felt we can run it for the yards." The only problem is the coaches were the only ones who thought so.
Near Studly -- Matt Ryan, BenJarvus Green-Ellis, Joe Flacco, Jay Cutler, Willis McGahee, Kerry Collins, Will Blackmon, Adrian Peterson, Peyton Manning and Clinton Hart.
Near Dudly -- Aaron Rodgers, Daunte Culpepper, Jake Delhomme, Drew Brees, Marshawn Lynch, Steve Slaton, Ben Roethlisberger, and Rex Grossman.
Studs and Duds
Duds: Marc Bulger and Trent Green
That's Bulger suffering the near-decapitation, but Green's day did not turn out much better. The two St. Louis quarterbacks combined to go 11-for-23 with three turnovers in a whopping 44-point loss.
Nick Laham, Getty Images
Stud: Brandon Jacobs
With the Giants facing a deficit in Philadelphia, they turned to their beefy running back and he delivered. Jacobs punched in two second-half touchdowns, while racking up 126 yards, as New York soared past the Eagles.
Chris Faytok, The Star-Ledger/US Presswire
Dud: Sage Rosenfels
No helicoptering fumbles this time, but Rosenfels (right) still had a miserable outing filling in for Matt Schaub. Baltimore picked off the Sage one four times, setting the table for a 41-13 rout in Houston.
David J. Phillip, AP
Stud: Thomas Jones
The Jets had plenty of Stud candidates emerge in a 47-3 thrashing of St. Louis, but Jones set the pace. The running back exploded for 149 rushing yards and three touchdowns on 26 carries.
Kathy Kmonicek, Newsday/MCT
Dud: Trent Edwards
Buffalo's quarterback has struggled lately, and his team has followed suit, losing three straight. On Sunday in New England, Edwards mustered just 120 passing yards and threw two interceptions.
Elise Amendola, AP
Stud: Maurice Jones-Drew
Sure, it may be easy to put up huge numbers against Detroit, but Jacksonville's backfield star deserves a tip of the cap anyway. Jones-Drew found the end zone a career-high three times against the Lions.
Jim McIsaac, Getty Images
Dud: Philadelphia Playcalling
Despite sporting Donovan McNabb under center, the Eagles took the ball out of his hands in crunch time and paid the price. Trailing late, Philly called back-to-back run plays on third and forth downs near midfield - and were stuffed both times to end any hope.
Tim Shaffer, Reuters
Stud: NFL Tight Ends
It was a big week for the league's talented tight end corps. Tony Gonzalez pulled in a last-second touchdown to nearly swipe a Chiefs' win in San Diego, while guys like Bo Scaife, Antonio Gates and Kellen Winslow had big weeks.
Lenny Ignelzi, AP





















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-10-2008 @ 12:38PM
Jim said...
A friend of mine always called the NFL the National Fixed League because each year it seemed like there were phantom flags appearing just in time to help a certain team he hated. I dismissed his assessment but I'm starting to wonder especially in watching the officiating this year. In particular I think the Vikings are getting lots of calls and it appears that the NFL wants the Vikings in the playoffs. Just this week did you see all of the phantom holding calls on the Packers everytime the Packers got something going. The announcers were questioning these calls too. Combine this with the phantom calls (especially the pass interference call that gave the Vikings the game) in the Detroit/Minnesota game a few weeks ago and even in the games the Vikings lost I think there is a bias in favor of the Vikings this year.
Reply
11-10-2008 @ 2:34PM
dubbz3030 said...
This is an easy on. MJD played the lions,, TJones played the rams. BJacobs plowed through the Eagles in Philly. The man's a Beast!!
Reply
11-10-2008 @ 4:11PM
JIM said...
Although I' m the biggest BEAR fan I know I still don't see how you failed to list Rex Grossman in your DUD category. Recievers wide open all day and he couldn't hit one. He stinks so bad he couldn't hit the floor with a dead cat.
Reply
11-10-2008 @ 4:31PM
gstarrpro said...
The Rams need to get a new coach and start over. The team is so deflated, I bet the top 5 college teams can whip them! I think Martyball would be a good coach to put fire under this team!!!
Reply
11-10-2008 @ 5:32PM
Randy said...
While Sage Rosenfels didn't exactly light things up, to say that he had a worse day than Jake Delhomme is just wrong. Delhomme threw for 72 yards and had four picks, Rosenfels actually threw for 294 and a 60 yard score along with his four picks. Fantasy points wise Sage was 14 points better than Jake.
Reply
11-10-2008 @ 5:49PM
Wade said...
Did you list Chris Johnson under dud's and I missed him?
Or did you miss him?
Reply
11-10-2008 @ 7:51PM
Will said...
Steve Smith wasn't a dud?? He had 1 catch for 9 yards
Reply
11-10-2008 @ 7:55PM
Dave said...
The Brown's D was the BIGGEST DUD. 560 yards and 34 points blowing a 13 point 3 rd quarter lead!
Reply
11-11-2008 @ 12:52AM
Paul said...
It is time for Andy Reid to take a walk. How many more games will be lost because of his idiot play calling. When it is crunch time and he runs the same stupid plays, do you think it is the players who are at fault, or his stupid play calling. He needs to grow a brain. Also, McNabb needs to practice throwing the ball TO receivers, not behind them or at their toes. After 10 years he should be able to do that. He might even try playing well for 3 quarters in a row. That would be a real change.
Reply
11-11-2008 @ 1:05AM
Brad said...
I am a bic Carolina fan but I think Jake Delhomme just thought he was playing at home. He kept throwing to the black jerseys. It was really ugly. Biggest dud of the week.
Reply
11-11-2008 @ 6:10AM
steve said...
In responce to bad calls. Yes , defensive linemen held offence and called other way. Why have instant replay if your not going to use it. Especially on critical calls. As for Phila vrs Giants. MR CHUNKY SOUP should of taken snap, And ran end around. If defender came up, Short pass out of backfield.
I'M missing something. If you only gain 29 yards on ground all game, Why give it to running back?. Its not going to change on one play. passing worked all game. Andy is starting to cost Eagles too many games.
Reply
11-11-2008 @ 1:59PM
armando montalvo said...
The game changing moment itn the Giants-Philly game was the overturned call that Eli didnt pass the line of scrimage on his pass. It seemed to take a lot of steam out of the Phil's defense and ended making the difference in the outcome of the final score. I still couldnt believe that they tried to pick up a first down by running on my Giants! Mcnabb could have sneezed a first down had he been given a chance!
Reply
11-14-2008 @ 8:05AM
Nick said...
No mention of Tyler Thigpen ? the man has no running attack and still threw 3 TDs.
Also Lendale White and Johnson were awful
Reply