
Here's how crazy the past weekend in the NFL was: The top eight teams in my power rankings went 0-6. The Giants, Redskins, Cowboys, Ravens, Broncos and Panthers all lost, while the Titans and Steelers were off.
So, even though the Tennessee Titans have played an easy schedule to become the only undefeated team in the league, for now I'm going to list them atop my NFL power rankings. Sorry if I can't get too enthused about it, Titans fans.
- 1. Titans (5-0) | Prev.: 4
There was one piece of bad news for the Titans this week: They lost a pick in the 2009 draft, compensation to the Cowboys for the suspension of Pacman Jones. Here's a piece of good news: The Titans no longer have to deal with Pacman Jones.
- 2. Giants (4-1) | Previous Week: 1
That Monday night loss to the Browns was just about the most lackluster effort any good team has put together all season, and yet I'll only drop them one spot on the power rankings since, as previously noted, all the other good teams lost, too. - 3. Steelers (4-1) | Prev.: 5
Getting defensive end Brett Keisel back from a calf strain is big for the Steelers' defense. Keisel had started every game for Pittsburgh in the last two-plus seasons, and his return will make a good defense better. - 4. Buccaneers (4-2) | Prev.: 10
Is there any doubt at all that Jeff Garcia is a better quarterback than Brian Griese? Jon Gruden gets his little quarterback crushes every season, and this season Griese was the object of his affection, but he seems to realize now that Garcia is his man.
- 5. Eagles (3-3) | Prev.: 9
This is a good team with an average record, and a good example of why the win-loss record doesn't tell you everything. According to Football Outsiders, the Eagles are the best team in the league. The problem is that the combination of three tough losses and being in the best division in the league leaves them little margin for error. - 6. Colts (3-2) | Prev.: 18
Peyton Manning is back to 100 percent, and that means the Colts are in good shape on offense. It's too bad the trade for defensive tackle John McCargo was voided, because an inability to stop the run is the one thing that could prevent the Colts from being one of the league's elite teams.
- 7. Bills (4-1) | Prev.: 12
Quarterback Trent Edwards and receiver/return man Roscoe Parrish are both healthy and ready to go Sunday against San Diego in a game that could go a long way toward securing the Bills' status as the favorites in the AFC East. - 8. Redskins (4-2) | Prev.: 2
A loss to the Rams is embarrassing, but I still think the Redskins are a solid, well-rounded team. I'm just not sure why they felt the need to sign a washed-up running back.
- 9. Panthers (4-2) | Prev.: 8
Panthers fullback Brad Hoover said that when the players hear from the coaches after their 27-3 loss to Tampa Bay, they should "not take criticism to a point where you get angry with it." I dunno. Maybe anger is the correct emotion after a loss that ugly.
- 10. Cowboys (4-2) | Prev.: 3
I love the trade for Roy Williams, one of the best young receivers in the league. Other than that, the Cowboys may have had the worst week that any NFL franchise has ever had. From Pacman Jones' suspension to an overtime loss that cost them Tony Romo, Felix Jones and Mat McBriar, plus Terence Newman needing surgery, this is a big mess. - 11. Broncos (4-2) | Prev.: 7
Running back Michael Pittman had an impressive game against the Jaguars. This offense has so many weapons, it's a shame that the defense is going to lose so many games for Denver.
- 12. Bears (3-3) | Prev.: 11
Was there any worse coaching strategery on display last weekend than Lovie Smith's decision to squib kick and then play a prevent Cover-2 in the closing seconds against the Falcons? Smith is a good coach, but he cost the Bears the game. - 13. Chargers (3-3) | Prev.: 13
The dominant win over the Patriots Sunday night was just the kind of thing that builds momentum. Except I think the Chargers' upcoming trip from San Diego to Buffalo to London and back to San Diego is just the kind of thing that kills momentum. - 14. Packers (3-3) | Prev.: 14
The thing I didn't like about the Packers' offense against Seattle was that Aaron Rodgers' passes were too short. Yes, they were accurate and effective, but I think to beat a team better than the Seahawks, they're going to need to hit Donald Driver with some downfield passes and not just dink and dunk, eight or nine yards at a time.
- 15. Ravens (2-3) | Prev.: 6
The Ravens are sticking with quarterback Joe Flacco, which is the right decision because really, what other decision do they have? His backup, Troy Smith, was a fifth-round draft pick last year who has missed a great deal of practice time after suffering a serious illness.
- 16. Saints (3-3) | Prev.: 16
The Saints have already lost 31 games by starters to injury through six games this season. They lost only 36 games by starters to injury all of last season .
- 17. Jaguars (3-3) | Prev.: 17
The Jaguars may have saved their season with that win over the Broncos. They're still right in the thick of things at 3-3. - 18. Cardinals (4-2) | Prev.: 22
Should the Cardinals be higher than this? Maybe. I love Kurt Warner and his receivers, but I just don't trust Arizona's defense to play as well all season as it played Sunday against the Cowboys. Arizona looks to me like a team that is going to win the NFC West and then get blown out at home by a wild card team in the first round of the playoffs. - 19. Patriots (3-2) | Prev.: 15
Bill Belichick's record as head coach of the Browns was 37-45. His record as head coach of the Patriots when Tom Brady isn't starting at quarterback is 7-15. Just sayin'. - 20. Jets (3-2) | Prev.: 20
With back to back games against Oakland and Kansas City coming up, we're going to see a lot of glowing articles about Brett Favre. I'd just like to see the Jets beat a good team. - 21. Falcons (4-2) | Prev.: 23
I know, I'm stubborn, I should have the Falcons higher than this. That's what Atlanta fans will say. I still say they have a hard road ahead to eight wins. - 22. Browns (2-3) | Prev.: 26
Where was the Browns team we saw on Monday night for the first five weeks of the season? Play like that a couple more times and I'll be convinced that Cleveland has a good team.
- 23. Vikings (3-3) | Prev.: 19
Yes, I dropped the Vikings after they won a game. Because needing a last-minute field goal at home against the Lions is about as unimpressive a win as a team can possibly have. - 24. Dolphins (2-3) | Prev.: 21
How did the Dolphins' defense not see that Matt Schaub game-winning quarterback draw coming? I shouted to my wife that he was going to run it in, not that she cared.
- 25. 49ers (2-4) | Prev.: 24
The columnists in San Francisco have already decided that head coach Mike Nolan is getting fired, and now they're just talking about who will replace him. I think they've got the right man for the job in their offensive coordinator, Mike Martz.
- 26. Raiders (1-4) | Prev.: 25
I have a feeling that new head coach Tom Cable woke up Monday morning, thought about that 34-3 loss to the Saints, and asked himself, "What the hell did I just get myself into?"
- 27. Seahawks (1-4) | Prev.: 27
The Seahawks are playing so badly that John Madden won't watch them.
- 28. Texans (1-4) | Prev.: 30
The Texans gave their fans an exciting win on Sunday, but that doesn't change the fact that their defense stinks.
- 29. Rams (1-4) | Prev.: 32
How did new coach Jim Haslett get the worst team in the league ready to beat a likely playoff team? I don't know, but if he replicates it Sunday against the Cowboys, the fans in Dallas are going to go insane.
- 30. Chiefs (1-4) | Prev.:29
I don't really get why they wouldn't trade Tony Gonzalez, seeing as the team is going nowhere and it couldn't hurt to add a draft pick. You know who else doesn't get it? Tony Gonzalez. At least he has some good reading material to get him through a dreadful season. - 31. Bengals (0-6) | Prev.: 28
Fans in Cincinnati have so little interest in seeing the Bengals that they're happy to sell their tickets at a loss. At least the mayor still likes them.
- 32. Lions (0-5) | Prev.: 31
By getting rid of Roy Williams and Jon Kitna, the Lions officially gave up on the season. It's too bad their season ticket holders can't get their money back.



















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
10-16-2008 @ 12:43PM
Jimmy said...
WOW... in no way, shape or form do the Eagles belong ranked higher than the Redskins. did they beat Dallas in Dallas? No. Did they beat The Redskins on their own home turf? No. so the Redskins have one fluke ugly lose and the Eagles are better cuz they beat the lowly 49ers? the patriots nearly didnt have their perfect season last year when they nearly (and should have) lost to the two worst teams in the league (the dolphins and the ravens) did that make them less of a team? No. Hell why dont we just make the Browns #1 for beating the Giants. The Eagles are last in the division but they're a better team than the Redskins and Cowboys. RIGHT... You must be drinking Mcnab's Koolaid...
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 12:42PM
Sandy said...
Why do you have to put the Titans at the top? Is Jeff Fisher holding a gun to your head?
Why not list them #10? Or #32 if they're just not that good? I don't think you're little column will effect them one bit.
Oh, you did it because they are the only undefeated team? They've beaten teams that have beaten the other teams below them? Oh, well...then I guess they've earned it.
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 8:35PM
James Spring said...
Titans earned it????? Why not!!! Why do so many of you
like to disrespect the Titans? Better than your team maybe....
They have not lost a game and you tell me they have only
played easy teams...... It sounds like a lot of whinning to me.
Maybe your team will do better next week!!!! GO TITANS!!!
12-24-2008 @ 11:33PM
david hipp said...
Is there a team out there can run over 30 total yards in the play offs. I'm talking about the Titans.... steelers, Colts, Ravens,could'nt do it....who's next....
12-24-2008 @ 11:28PM
david hipp said...
Let's FACE IT Titans Rank #1 over all....Deal with it, Maybe your team next year will be just as good!!!!!!!!
10-16-2008 @ 12:55PM
Brian Grummell said...
The Ravens must hate the scheduling Gods. They've already faced the No. 1,3 and 6 teams this year.
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 2:00PM
nathan.meyers said...
Don't worry. Titan's fans don't care one bit about your rankings. They are completely useless. Just by putting the Titans at number 1 for default just shows everyone that you don't have enough guts to really say who you think is number one. The only team the Giants have beaten is the Redskins. It was the first game of the year, in New York and they had a new coach so they had no chance. Their next best win was Seattle which is your 27th best team. Their loss came from your 22nd team Cleveland. Who has the 16th ranked Defense and 28th Ranked offense.
Also if you are going to jump Indy up 12 points because Peyton looks like the Peyton of old then why wouldn't you drop the Giants because Eli looked like the Eli of old?
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 1:18PM
Jonathan said...
In response to Atlanta at #21...they may have a hard road ahead to eight wins, but if they finish with eight wins you would have them higher than 21. Just like you might not want to rank the Titans 1, you might not want to put the Falcons in the top 10/15, but, at 4-2, they deserve to be there.
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 1:19PM
Mike said...
Is this a joke? A .500 (who barely beat the niners) team in the top 5? You might want to leave this sort of thing to people who are intellegent.
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 2:12PM
Vanessa said...
Your lack of enthusiasm? I'm sorry but I'm more than sure the Titans could care less about rather or not your heart was in your choice. If you listed them as Number 1 because you felt you had to and not because they are the only undefeated team in the NFL then perhaps you're a little confused about your job title. Default? The Titans are playing the schedule they were given, just like the Giants and all of the other top teams you listed, and rather you respect their abilities or not they are the best at this particular moment. Who knows what will happen in the upcoming weeks but "by default" should not be the reason you put theTitans in first place at this time. It's because of their record.
Reply
10-17-2008 @ 3:11AM
BobbyStompy said...
Nice anti-Pats bias, MDS. I'm sorry BB didn't answer your irrelevant Rodney Harrison HGH question at the Super Bowl, but was them not losing the game enough for you to cool your jets? Keep sippin' that haterade.
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 3:30PM
Eric the Man said...
why are the Eagles ranked higher then The Redskins and Cowboys? Both teams have beat them and currently hold a better overall record in league and division play.
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 3:30PM
e-rock said...
Why are the Eagles ranked higher then the Redskins and the Cowboys? The Eagles lost to both of these teams, have a worse overall record, and are last in that division
Reply
10-21-2008 @ 8:17PM
No-matter-what-always-a-redskin-fan said...
i totally agree that who ever made this power ranking sucks! Some one else make one man, this guy did a lousy job! why are eagles higher than Redskin and Dallas! I think he's a eagles fan so he ranked them higher than Redskins and Dallas!
10-16-2008 @ 3:34PM
rob said...
you are the biggest idiot to ever assemble a weekly power ranking.....are you on the eagles payroll or what? the skins barely lost to a crummy team, while the giants got absolutely obliterated by a crummy team. your rankings make no sense!
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 3:44PM
PacoGerte said...
You kind of have to weigh the record in these rankings. Most people would rate the Bills over the Chargers, but Vegas has the Chargers favored by 1.5 points at Buffalo, for instance.
Reply
10-16-2008 @ 10:27PM
lowridersteeler said...
the only team that should be no1 are the steelers and the reason being is they have the toughest schedule of all the teams combined,so just for that they should be no1, everyone else should take note, on how to play in the toughest schedule plus,having all the injuries along with it ,that just shows how the players of the steelers really do compliment their name,tough just like nails more than i can say for some whinning and cheating teams, i wont mentin any names ,cowpaddies and ne cheaters hahahahahaha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! punk idiots ,all of you so called bad ass teams should go to pittsburgh and learn how to play with adversity,bunch of sissies
Reply
10-19-2008 @ 6:46AM
Jeff said...
Your sissy steelers are coming to our house 11/3. Why don't you come down to Fed-Ex for the hanging. Go Redskins!
12-25-2008 @ 7:49AM
David Hipp said...
For the record you sports reporters and NFL Media personal you want to rank steelers #1 Defence in the NFL. Lets get real for a top rank team, looks like to me and the rest of the World the Tennessee Titans Has the best Defence in the AFC and the NFC. FACE IT LIKE IT OR NOT TITANS WILL BE THE NEXT SUPERBOWL CHAMPS. 2008 No team out there can beat them the way they play Defence. So give the Titans the respect they well deserve.........they earned it...!!!!!!
10-16-2008 @ 5:13PM
Nathan said...
What don't you understand about the Redskins' Alexander signing? Is there a better back on the market available for the vet minimum that is willing to sign for 3-4 weeks while Betts recovers from his injury?
Reply