
Punters are often overlooked as necessities, but not "real football players" or some such silliness. It's all fun and games until the special teams costs you a game. Then, not so much. That's why Andy Lee and Mike Scifres are so well regarded -- and appreciated -- by their teams.
Anyway, in an effort to beef up its special teams, the Steelers used a fourth-round pick on Daniel Sepulveda. Not a very well received move in some parts of the Pittsburgh media; in fact, one writer suggested the team would've been better off with Mike Barr, the free agent that was annually invited to Steelers training camp only to lose the job to whoever the competition was.
Like clockwork, Barr lost out to Sepulveda, was released, but did land a job with the Cardinals. That lasted 11 games until Arizona sent him packing earlier this week. The reason? He was awful, of course. And even without looking at the stats, the fact that the Cards invited Mitch Berger, Tom Rouen and Chris Gardocki to compete for the job is reason enough to think that Barr wasn't faring very well. (For the three of you who care, Berger won the job. Season saved in the desert.)
And for anybody else who thinks punters aren't important, here's what Dr. Z had to say following the Steelers-Dolphins Monday night game:
You know how the Dolphins could have beaten [the Steelers] on Monday night? With superior punting, something that would have put the Steelers in a hole. It never happened. It's always amazed me, why an NFL team can't spend a couple of million or so to sign the most dynamic punter in the game. They're always yacking about how important special teams are, yet they won't spend a quarter to fortify that unit. It goes back to college, where I've seen some really high-powered teams with some scared-faced punter, popping a little weenie of a 3.4 hanger, shaking his head, etc. I mean how tough would it be to recruit some really dynamite high school boomer and give him a lovely scholarship and a job for his girlfriend and grandfather and whatever else he wants?The lesson: Punters are people too. Learn it. Know it. Live it.



















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
12-01-2007 @ 10:40PM
twoeightnine said...
At least Buffalo has gotten this aspect right.
Reply
12-01-2007 @ 11:20PM
tobrien28 said...
Another great punter you forgot to mention: Jeff Feagles. Time after time he pins opposing offenses behind the ten. For anyone who still doesn't think special teams are important watch a few Virginia Tech games and count the great special teams plays.
Reply
12-01-2007 @ 11:44PM
Eric said...
Shane Lechler is the best....granted he gets alot of practice.
Reply
12-02-2007 @ 1:26AM
viking999 said...
Absolutely right about punters. Heck with those who don't care. Dr. Z is so right on. Just sign a great
one and let him save you over and over. Amazing how some teams can't recognize the serious nature of the
punting game as a part of special teams play. Oh
well, those are the teams that just lose often and NEVER understand why !
Reply
12-02-2007 @ 2:27AM
ryan said...
Special Teams still only account for 1/7th of the game (see Football Outsiders for details), but improving that 1/7th can definitely win games. Some argue that one of the main problems for the Seahawks in the Super Bowl was punting, so they went out and drafted Pleickermeier (sp?). If you could somehow create a punter that pinned the opponent inside the 5 every time you punted, wouldn't he be the most valuable player in football?
Reply